Minding the gap
There has been persistent and unmoving gender diversity in AI for a while. In 2019, women accounted for 22 percent of all AI and computer science PhD programs in North America, just 4 percent higher than the same statistical category from 2010.
So what is driving this sustained gender gap in AI, and how can we address it?
This Women in AI whitepaper, in which Deloitte interviewed women who have risen to AI leadership positions within their organizations in addition to surveying individuals working in AI, unpacks the roots of the gender gap in AI, provides a potential path for organizations to fix it, and shows how businesses that do not could be handicapping themselves.
Percentage of women in US labor workforce
Why gender diversity matters
Today, evidence is reinforcing that gender diversity, particularly among leadership positions, drives increased productivity, profitability, and market value for organizations across industries:
- Goldman Sachs research found that companies with "diverse" boards (Goldman did not define "diverse," but said the emphasis was on women) performed stronger in public markets. Organizations with at least one diverse board member increased their average share price by 44 percent in their first year after going public, a significantly higher figure than companies with no diverse members (13 percent).
- Research from the MSCI Women’s Leadership Index shows that, since 2016, publicly traded large-, mid-, and small-cap companies in the United States, Canada, and Europe that prioritize gender diversity among their executive leadership and board of directors have yielded higher net returns in their respective equity markets than companies not committing to gender diversity.
- An HBR study analyzing the connection between productivity and gender diversity found that, among Western European companies, a 10 percent increase in the ratio of women to men in the workforce correlated with a 7 percent increase in market value.
The business case
Deloitte’s survey with women and men working in AI and machine learning further demonstrated that having more women within an organization can only beneﬁt a business.
Respondents strongly agreed:
Companies that promote and elevate diverse groups within their organization will beneﬁt as a result.
Having more women in managerial, leadership, and role model positions directly beneﬁts an organization’s employees.
Data shows that companies with diverse and inclusive cultures are betting on fueling productivity and innovation within their workforces, translating into better products, a competitive edge over peers, and improved sales and profit. Within AI, the importance of diversity has been well documented as well: In order to build an effective AI system—including defining a problem for AI to solve, designing a solution, selecting and preparing the data inputs, and constructing and training the algorithms—an AI team should be as diverse as the populations that its AI will impact.
Levers for diversity include gender, race, socioeconomic background, work experience, age, ability, privilege, and experience with discrimination, among others. Having diversity across a number of criteria helps ensure a wide range of perspectives and lived experiences are incorporated into the design and implementation of an AI system. Because of the need for AI teams to reflect the populations they intend to address, and given that half of the world’s population is female, as AWS’ Allie Miller (Global Head of Machine Learning Business Development, Startups and Venture Capital) put it, having more gender diversity within AI is a matter of "common sense."
The AI case
Deloitte’s survey with women and men working in AI and machine learning reinforced that having more women in the space improves the design and functionality of AI systems.
Respondents strongly agreed:
Adding women to AI and machine learning will bring unique perspectives to high tech that are needed in the industry.
AI and machine learning solutions would benefit from having more diverse employees in designer and developer positions.
AI and machine learning models would always produce biased results as long as AI continues to be a male-dominated field.
The importance of diversity within AI teams is connected to one of the biggest challenges facing AI today: biases within AI systems. While most AI bias is unintentional and goes unnoticed, if AI systems perpetuate existing forms of gender bias, they will fail to reach their fullest capacity and could ultimately hinder organizations’ progress in implementing AI effectively. At best, the algorithms should be retooled after being evaluated. At worst, organizations could face regulatory or reputational risks.
A more diverse workforce is better tooled to identify and remove AI biases as they interpret data, test solutions, and make decisions. Specific to gender, women are likely to catch things men might miss (and vice versa). In this regard, gender diversity can benefit AI development.