Domain-adaptation Fine-tuning of Foundation Models in Amazon SageMaker JumpStart on Financial data

Large language models (LLMs) with billions of parameters are currently at the forefront of natural language processing (NLP). These models are shaking up the field with their incredible abilities to generate text, analyze sentiment, translate languages, and much more. With access to massive amounts of data, LLMs have the potential to revolutionize the way we interact with language. Although LLMs are capable of performing various NLP tasks, they are considered generalists and not specialists. In order to train an LLM to become an expert in a particular domain, fine-tuning is usually required.

One of the major challenges in training and deploying LLMs with billions of parameters is their size, which can make it difficult to fit them into single GPUs, the hardware commonly used for deep learning. The sheer scale of these models requires high-performance computing resources, such as specialized GPUs with large amounts of memory. Additionally, the size of these models can make them computationally expensive, which can significantly increase training and inference times.

In this post, we demonstrate how we can use Amazon SageMaker JumpStart to easily fine-tune a large language text generation model on a domain-specific dataset in the same way you would train and deploy any model on Amazon SageMaker. In particular, we show how you can fine-tune the GPT-J 6B language model for financial text generation using both the JumpStart SDK and Amazon SageMaker Studio UI on a publicly available dataset of SEC filings.

JumpStart helps you quickly and easily get started with machine learning (ML) and provides a set of solutions for the most common use cases that can be trained and deployed readily with just a few steps. All the steps in this demo are available in the accompanying notebook Fine-tuning text generation GPT-J 6B model on a domain specific dataset.

Solution overview

In the following sections, we provide a step-by-step demonstration for fine-tuning an LLM for text generation tasks via both the JumpStart Studio UI and Python SDK. In particular, we discuss the following topics:

• An overview of the SEC filing data in the financial domain that the model is fine-tuned on
• An overview of the LLM GPT-J 6B model we have chosen to fine-tune
• A demonstration of two different ways we can fine-tune the LLM using JumpStart:
  • Use JumpStart programmatically with the SageMaker Python SDK
  • Access JumpStart using the Studio UI
• An evaluation of the fine-tuned model by comparing it with the pre-trained model without fine-tuning

Fine-tuning refers to the process of taking a pre-trained language model and training it for a different but related task using specific data. This approach is also known as transfer learning, which involves transferring the knowledge learned from one task to another. LLMs like GPT-J 6B are trained on massive amounts of unlabeled data and can be fine-tuned on smaller datasets, making the model perform better in a specific domain.

As an example of how performance improves when the model is fine-tuned, consider asking it the following question:

“What drives sales growth at Amazon?”

Without fine-tuning, the response would be:

“Amazon is the world’s largest online retailer. It is also the world’s largest online marketplace. It is also the world”

With fine tuning, the response is:

“Sales growth at Amazon is driven primarily by increased customer usage, including increased selection, lower prices, and increased convenience, and increased sales by other sellers on our websites.”

The improvement from fine-tuning is evident.

We use financial text from SEC filings to fine-tune a GPT-J 6B LLM for financial applications. In the next sections, we introduce the data and the LLM that will be fine-tuned.

SEC filing dataset

SEC filings are critical for regulation and disclosure in finance. Filings notify the investor community about companies’ business conditions and the future outlook of the companies. The text in SEC filings covers the entire gamut of a company’s operations and business conditions. Because of their potential predictive value, these filings are good sources of information for investors. Although these SEC filings are publicly available to anyone, downloading parsed filings and constructing a clean dataset with added features is a time-consuming exercise. We make this possible in a few API calls in the JumpStart Industry SDK.

Using the SageMaker API, we downloaded annual reports (10-K filings; see How to Read a 10-K for more information) for a large number of companies. We select Amazon’s SEC filing reports for years 2021–2022 as the training data to fine-tune the GPT-J 6B model. In particular, we concatenate the SEC filing reports of the company in different years into a single text file except for the “Management Discussion and Analysis” section, which contains forward-looking statements by the company’s management and are used as the validation data.

The expectation is that after fine-tuning the GPT-J 6B text generation model on the financial SEC documents, the model is able to generate insightful financial related textual output, and therefore can be used to solve multiple domain-specific NLP tasks.

GPT-J 6B large language model

GPT-J 6B is an open-source, 6-billion-parameter model released by Eleuther AI. GPT-J 6B has been trained on a large corpus of text data and is capable of performing various NLP tasks such as text generation, text classification, and text summarization. Although this model is impressive on a number of NLP tasks without the need for any fine-tuning, in many cases you will need to fine-tune the model on a specific dataset and NLP tasks you are trying to solve for. Use cases include custom chatbots, idea generation, entity extraction, classification, and sentiment analysis.

Access LLMs on SageMaker

Now that we have identified the dataset and the model we are going to fine-tune on, JumpStart provides two avenues to get started using text generation fine-tuning: the SageMaker SDK and Studio.

Use JumpStart programmatically with the SageMaker SDK

We now go over an example of how you can use the SageMaker JumpStart SDK to access an LLM (GPT-J 6B) and fine-tune it on the SEC filing dataset. Upon completion of fine-tuning, we will deploy the fine-tuned model and make inference against it. All the steps in this post are available in the accompanying notebook: Fine-tuning text generation GPT-J 6B model on domain specific dataset.

In this example, JumpStart uses the SageMaker Hugging Face Deep Learning Container (DLC) and DeepSpeed library to fine-tune the model. The DeepSpeed library is designed to reduce computing power and memory use and to train large distributed models with better parallelism on existing computer hardware. It supports single node distributed training, utilizing gradient checkpointing and model parallelism to train large models on a single SageMaker training instance with multiple GPUs. With JumpStart, we integrate the DeepSpeed library with the SageMaker Hugging Face DLC for you and take care of everything under the hood. You can easily fine-tune the model on your domain-specific dataset without manually setting it up.

Fine-tune the pre-trained model on domain-specific data

To fine-tune a selected model, we need to get that model’s URI, as well as the training script and the container image used for training. To make things easy, these three inputs depend solely on the model name, version (for a list of the available models, see Built-in Algorithms with pre-trained Model Table), and the type of instance you want to train on. This is demonstrated in the following code snippet:

from sagemaker import image_uris, model_uris, script_uris, hyperparameters

model_id, model_version = "huggingface-textgeneration1-gpt-j-6b", "*"
training_instance_type = "ml.g5.12xlarge"

# Retrieve the docker image
train_image_uri = image_uris.retrieve(
    region=None,
    framework=None,
    model_id=model_id,
    model_version=model_version,
    image_scope="training",
    instance_type=training_instance_type,
)

# Retrieve the training script
train_source_uri = script_uris.retrieve(
    model_id=model_id, model_version=model_version, script_scope="training"
)

# Retrieve the pre-trained model tarball to further fine-tune
train_model_uri = model_uris.retrieve(
    model_id=model_id, model_version=model_version, model_scope="training"
)

We retrieve the model_id corresponding to the same model we want to use. In this case, we fine-tune huggingface-textgeneration1-gpt-j-6b.

Defining hyperparameters involves setting the values for various parameters used during the training process of an ML model. These parameters can affect the model’s performance and accuracy. In the following step, we establish the hyperparameters by utilizing the default settings and specifying custom values for parameters such as epochs and learning_rate:

from sagemaker import hyperparameters

# Retrieve the default hyper-parameters for fine-tuning the model
hyperparameters = hyperparameters.retrieve_default(model_id=model_id, model_version=model_version)

# [Optional] Override default hyperparameters with custom values
hyperparameters["epochs"] = "6"

hyperparameters["learning_rate"] = "2e-04"
print(hyperparameters)

JumpStart provides an extensive list of hyperparameters available to tune. The following list provides an overview of part of the key hyperparameters utilized in fine-tuning the model. For a full list of hyperparameters, see the notebook Fine-tuning text generation GPT-J 6B model on domain specific dataset.

• epochs – Specifies at most how many epochs of the original dataset will be iterated.
• learning_rate – Controls the step size or learning rate of the optimization algorithm during training.
• eval_steps – Specifies how many steps to run before evaluating the model on the validation set during training. The validation set is a subset of the data that is not used for training, but instead is used to check the performance of the model on unseen data.
• weight_decay – Controls the regularization strength during model training. Regularization is a technique that helps prevent the model from overfitting the training data, which can result in better performance on unseen data.
• fp16 – Controls whether to use fp16 16-bit (mixed) precision training instead of 32-bit training.
• evaluation_strategy – The evaluation strategy used during training.
• gradient_accumulation_steps – The number of updates steps to accumulate the gradients for, before performing a backward/update pass.

For further details regarding hyperparameters, refer to the official Hugging Face Trainer documentation.

You can now fine-tune this JumpStart model on your own custom dataset using the SageMaker SDK. We use the SEC filing data we described earlier. The train and validation data is hosted under train_dataset_s3_path and validation_dataset_s3_path. The supported format of the data includes CSV, JSON, and TXT. For the CSV and JSON data, the text data is used from the column called text or the first column if no column called text is found. Because this is for text generation fine-tuning, no ground truth labels are required. The following code is an SDK example of how to fine-tune the model:

from sagemaker.estimator import Estimator
from sagemaker.utils import name_from_base
from sagemaker.tuner import HyperparameterTuner
from sagemaker.huggingface import HuggingFace

train_dataset_s3_path = "s3://jumpstart-cache-prod-us-west-2/training-datasets/tc/data.csv"
validation_dataset_s3_path = "s3://jumpstart-cache-prod-us-west-2/training-datasets/tc/data.csv"

training_job_name = name_from_base(f"jumpstart-example-{model_id}")

metric_definitions=[
    {'Name': 'train:loss', 'Regex': "'loss': ([0-9]+\.[0-9]+)"},
    {'Name': 'eval:loss', 'Regex': "'eval_loss': ([0-9]+\.[0-9]+)"},
    {'Name': 'eval:runtime', 'Regex': "'eval_runtime': ([0-9]+\.[0-9]+)"},
    {'Name': 'eval:samples_per_second', 'Regex': "'eval_samples_per_second': ([0-9]+\.[0-9]+)"},
    {'Name': 'eval:eval_steps_per_second', 'Regex': "'eval_steps_per_second': ([0-9]+\.[0-9]+)"},
]

# # Create SageMaker Estimator instance
tg_estimator = Estimator(
    role=aws_role,
    image_uri=train_image_uri,
    source_dir=train_source_uri,
    model_uri=train_model_uri,
    entry_point="transfer_learning.py",
    instance_count=1,
    instance_type=training_instance_type,
    hyperparameters=hyperparameters,
    output_path=s3_output_location,
    base_job_name=training_job_name,
    enable_network_isolation=True,
    metric_definitions=metric_definitions
)

# Launch a SageMaker Training job by passing s3 path of the training data
tg_estimator.fit({"train": train_dataset_s3_path, "validation": validation_dataset_s3_path}, logs=True)

After we have set up the SageMaker Estimator with the required hyperparameters, we instantiate a SageMaker estimator and call the .fit method to start fine-tuning our model, passing it the Amazon Simple Storage Service (Amazon S3) URI for our training data. As you can see, the entry_point script provided is named transfer_learning.py (the same for other tasks and models), and the input data channel passed to .fit must be named train and validation.

JumpStart also supports hyperparameter optimization with SageMaker automatic model tuning. For details, see the example notebook.

Deploy the fine-tuned model

When training is complete, you can deploy your fine-tuned model. To do so, all we need to obtain is the inference script URI (the code that determines how the model is used for inference once deployed) and the inference container image URI, which includes an appropriate model server to host the model we chose. See the following code:

from sagemaker.predictor import Predictor
from sagemaker import image_uris
from sagemaker.utils import name_from_base
import boto3

sagemaker_session = sagemaker.Session(boto_session=boto3.Session(region_name="us-west-2"))

#Retrieve the inference docker container uri
deploy_image_uri = image_uris.retrieve(
    region=None,
    framework=None,
    image_scope="inference",
    model_id=model_id,
    model_version=model_version,
    instance_type=inference_instance_type,
)
    
endpoint_name = name_from_base(f"jumpstart-example-{model_id}")

# Use the estimator from the previous step to deploy to a SageMaker endpoint
finetuned_predictor = tg_estimator.deploy(
    initial_instance_count=1,
    instance_type="ml.g5.12xlarge",
    image_uri=image_uri,
    endpoint_name=endpoint_name,
)

After a few minutes, our model is deployed and we can get predictions from it in real time!

Access JumpStart through the Studio UI

Another way to fine-tune and deploy JumpStart models is through the Studio UI. This UI provides a low-code/no-code solution to fine-tuning LLMs.

On the Studio console, choose Models, notebooks, solutions under SageMaker JumpStart in the navigation pane.

In the search bar, search for the model you want to fine-tune and deploy.

In our case, we chose the GPT-J 6B model card. Here we can directly fine-tune or deploy the LLM.

Model evaluation

When evaluating an LLM, we can use perplexity (PPL). PPL is a common measure of how well a language model is able to predict the next word in a sequence. In simpler terms, it’s a way to measure how well the model can understand and generate human-like language.

A lower perplexity score means that the model is shown to perform better at predicting the next word. In practical terms, we can use perplexity to compare different language models and determine which one performs better on a given task. We can also use it to track the performance of a single model over time. For more details, refer to Perplexity of fixed-length models.

We evaluate the model’s performance through a comparison of its pre- and post-fine-tuning performance. PPL is emitted in the training job’s Amazon CloudWatch logs. In addition, we look at the output generated by the model in response to specific test prompts.

The model’s enhanced performance is demonstrated by two experiments:

• Text generation – We show that the output the fine-tuned GPT-J generates text that has a resemblance to the SEC dataset, indicating that it has learned to emulate the language patterns and conventions of the financial regulatory domain
• Zero-shot learning – We demonstrate that the fine-tuned GPT-J shows significantly better performance than the non-fine-tuned GPT-J on zero-shot question answering

For the text generation experiment, we use the following inference parameters to achieve our results: max_length of 400 (number of tokens returned), num_return_sequences of 1 (number of response text examples), top_k of 250 (pick from one of the top 250 possible continuations), top_p of 0.8 (select only from continuations that are at least 80% probable), do_sample is True (sampling), and temperature of 1 (high temperature is greater randomness in responses). For more details about the parameters, refer to GenerationConfig. The following table compares the fine-tuned GPT-J and non-fine-tuned one on a text completion task.

For the second experiment with a zero-shot question answering task, we set the max_length to be a different value (40, 200, and 40, respectively) based on the output we expect from each question. The parameters of top_k, top_p, do_sample, temperature are set as 250, 0.8, False, and 0, respectively. We set temperature close to 0 to control the randomness of the output, whereas in the text generation task we set it close to 1 to make the model more creative. The following table compares the results. For each question, the output from fine-tuned GPT-J is more accurate than the non-fine-tuned one.

Clean up

To avoid ongoing charges, delete the SageMaker inference endpoints. You can delete the endpoints via the SageMaker console or from the notebook using the following commands:

# Delete the SageMaker endpoint and the attached resources
finetuned_predictor.delete_model()
finetuned_predictor.delete_endpoint()

Conclusion

JumpStart is a capability in SageMaker that allows you to quickly get started with ML. JumpStart uses open-source, pre-trained models to solve common ML problems like image classification, object detection, text classification, sentence pair classification, and question answering.

In this post, we showed you how to fine-tune and deploy a pre-trained LLM (GPT-J 6B) for text generation based on the SEC filling dataset. We demonstrated how the model transformed into a finance domain expert by undergoing the fine-tuning process on just two annual reports of the company. This fine-tuning enabled the model to generate content with an understanding of financial topics and greater precision. Try out the solution on your own and let us know how it goes in the comments.

Important: This post is for demonstrative purposes only. It is not financial advice and should not be relied on as financial or investment advice. The post used models pre-trained on data obtained from the SEC EDGAR database. You are responsible for complying with EDGAR’s access terms and conditions if you use SEC data.

To learn more about JumpStart, check out the following posts:

• Run text generation with Bloom and GPT models on Amazon SageMaker JumpStart
• Generate images from text with the stable diffusion model on Amazon SageMaker JumpStart
• AlexaTM 20B is now available in Amazon SageMaker JumpStart
• Run image segmentation with Amazon SageMaker JumpStart
• Amazon SageMaker JumpStart models and algorithms now available via API
• Incremental training with Amazon SageMaker JumpStart
• Transfer learning for TensorFlow object detection models in Amazon SageMaker
• Transfer learning for TensorFlow text classification models in Amazon SageMaker
• Transfer learning for TensorFlow image classification models in Amazon SageMaker

About the Authors

Dr. Xin Huang is a Senior Applied Scientist for Amazon SageMaker JumpStart and Amazon SageMaker built-in algorithms. He focuses on developing scalable machine learning algorithms. His research interests are in the area of natural language processing, explainable deep learning on tabular data, and robust analysis of non-parametric space-time clustering. He has published many papers in ACL, ICDM, KDD conferences, and Royal Statistical Society: Series A.

Marc Karp is an ML Architect with the Amazon SageMaker Service team. He focuses on helping customers design, deploy, and manage ML workloads at scale. In his spare time, he enjoys traveling and exploring new places.

Dr. Sanjiv Das is an Amazon Scholar and the Terry Professor of Finance and Data Science at Santa Clara University. He holds post-graduate degrees in Finance (M.Phil and PhD from New York University) and Computer Science (MS from UC Berkeley), and an MBA from the Indian Institute of Management, Ahmedabad. Prior to being an academic, he worked in the derivatives business in the Asia-Pacific region as a Vice President at Citibank. He works on multimodal machine learning in the area of financial applications.

Arun Kumar Lokanatha is a Senior ML Solutions Architect with the Amazon SageMaker Service team. He focuses on helping customers build, train, and migrate ML production workloads to SageMaker at scale. He specializes in deep learning, especially in the area of NLP and CV. Outside of work, he enjoys running and hiking.