The only benefit of the solution is collaboration. When I assign tasks, my team members get an email, and they can click on it and update their tasks. Smartsheet’s reporting capabilities help us with capacity planning.
Smartsheet
SmartsheetExternal reviews
External reviews are not included in the AWS star rating for the product.
Experiences with smartsheet
The tool is good for collaboration, but it is expensive and lacks features that are available in other products
How has it helped my organization?
What is most valuable?
Smartsheet is a really good tool for collaboration. If I put somebody’s name into an assignment, they get an email. They know what they’re being assigned, and they can access it. I don't have to run around chasing people. The emails help in workflow efficiency. In terms of overall planning, capacity consolidation across plans is quite useful, but it takes a lot of effort to get it to work properly. It's not that intelligent, but it's better than Microsoft Project. From a workflow perspective, it's pretty powerful.
What needs improvement?
I do not like the solution. From a project management and planning point of view, it's awful. The product must adopt some of the functionalities that are already in Microsoft Project. They must adopt functionalities like auto-scheduling, linking tasks together automatically, and scheduling based on the dependencies.
We have to manually put in every dependency in Smartsheet. It is incredibly annoying. In Microsoft Project, we just highlight the two that we want to link and click the link option, and it makes them dependent.
For how long have I used the solution?
I have been using the solution for six months.
What do I think about the stability of the solution?
The tool’s stability is fine.
What do I think about the scalability of the solution?
The tool is very easy to scale. It seems unlimited. It's certainly within our requirements. Five or six people use it within one business unit in our organization. There might be more users in other teams. It is an engineering company. So, we use the product throughout the world.
Which solution did I use previously and why did I switch?
Microsoft Project is way quicker for actual active planning. We have moved to Smartsheet because we've got a geographically distributed team. Now, I create the project in Microsoft Project and put it into Smartsheet for collaboration. Microsoft Project is way more functionally rich, so things are quicker. The ROI on Microsoft Project would be higher than on Smartsheet.
How was the initial setup?
There is no deployment needed. We just create Smartsheet and share. It does not require maintenance.
What's my experience with pricing, setup cost, and licensing?
The solution is too expensive. For what I use it for, it's too expensive. I wouldn't pay for it myself. I would prefer to buy Microsoft Project or use Zoho Projects.
Which other solutions did I evaluate?
I am currently evaluating Zoho Projects for my own use.
What other advice do I have?
Overall, I rate the product a six out of ten.
Drives efficiency but isn't aesthetically pleasing (alot to be desired)
- Application is quick and easy to load (windows). Having the app bookmarked to my homescreen means it's only ever one click away. Additionally updates are little and often which caused no disruption to service.
- Automation / sequencing events in project management. The ability to move one date, which then automatically moves all of the others saves a lot of time (from manual updates)
- Generally lots of pre-made templates which are easy to use. I often find even when I do use Google to help, Smartsheet often provides the most valuable direction/templates with clear instructions on how to use.
- Strong Reliability: As far as tools go, during my time using the app it hasn't been 'down' once (whether this be maintaince or unexpected interuption)
- Foldering system / navigation is easy to understand, enabling ease of use
- Despite having auto save switched on, I find myself constantly having to save when jumping between different sheets which carries risk of updates being lost. It would be great if auto save can save after any amend
- Email Notifications have a lot to be desired aesthetically. They tend to look and feel more like SPAM and not personal, which means recievers can often ignore
- Reporting / views are not easy to manage - still haven't been able to product a PDF successfully of a GANTT chart which can be understood by others
- Guidance on how to maximise notifications would be preferred as it can be very easy to over spam users with notifications unintentionally
Smartsheet typically has plenty of templated options available for usage, so when trying to improve existing processes or start something knew Smartsheet is typically the first place i'll go to start my search.
Whilst we haven't found a visualisation solution for calendar distribution via email, when viewing in the tool it is easy to manipulate into the specific views a user needs.
It is a user friendly system, you can basically figure out everything by yourself.
Smartsheet: plan and gantt
Great tool with potential to improve
SS is accisible to users who are not necessarily familiar with other tools used in product development.
Very convenient for somethings but struggling with others
- Adding comments to row
- Adding subrows (children)
- Seeing historical content cell
- Seeign author of every cell comment
- It is possible to create only one title
- Less freedom than in excel
- I would be helpful creating a comment per cell
- Not possible to create macros