How to automatically archive expected IAM Access Analyzer findings
AWS Identity and Access Management (IAM) Access Analyzer continuously monitors your Amazon Web Services (AWS) resource-based policies for changes in order to identify resources that grant public or cross-account access from outside your AWS account or organization. Access Analyzer findings include detailed information that you can use to make an informed decision about whether access to the shared resource was intended or not. The findings information includes the affected AWS resource, the external principal that has access, the condition from the policy statement that grants the access, and the access level, such as read, write, or the ability to modify permissions.
In this blog post, we show you how to automatically archive Access Analyzer findings for expected events, such as authorized resource access. The benefit of automatically archiving expected findings is to help you reduce distraction from findings that don’t require action, enabling you to concentrate on remediating any unexpected access to your shared resources.
Access Analyzer provides you with the ability to archive findings that show intended cross-account sharing of your AWS resources. The AWS service-provided archive mechanism provides you with built-in archive rules that can automatically archive new findings that meet the criteria you define (such as directive controls). For example, your organizational access controls might allow your auditor to have read-only IAM role cross-account access from your security account into all of your accounts. In this security auditor scenario, you can define a built-in archive rule to automatically archive the findings related to the auditor cross-account IAM role that has authorized read-only access.
A limitation of the built-in archive rules is that they are static and based only on simple pattern matching. To build your own custom archiving logic, you can create an AWS Lambda function that listens to Amazon CloudWatch Events. Access Analyzer forwards all findings to CloudWatch Events, and you can easily configure a CloudWatch Events rule to trigger a Lambda function for each Access Analyzer finding. For example, if you want to look up the tags on a resource, you can make an AWS API call based on the Amazon Resource Name (ARN) for the resource in your Lambda function. As another example, you might want to compute an overall risk score based on the various parts of a finding and archive everything below a certain threshold score that you define.
In this blog post, we show you how to configure a built-in archive rule, how to add context enrichment for more complex rules, and how to trigger an alert for unintended findings. We first cover the scenario of the auditor role using a built-in archive rule. Then, we show how to perform automated archive remediation by using CloudWatch Events with AWS Step Functions to add context enrichment and automatically remediate the authorized sharing of a cross-account AWS Key Management Service (AWS KMS) key. Finally, we show how to trigger alerts for the unintended sharing of a public Amazon Simple Storage Service (Amazon S3) bucket.
The solution we give here assumes that you have Access Analyzer enabled in your AWS account. You can find more details about enabling Access Analyzer in the Getting Started guide for that feature. Access Analyzer is available at no additional cost in the IAM console and through APIs in all commercial AWS Regions. Access Analyzer is also available through APIs in the AWS GovCloud (US) Regions.
How to use the built-in archive rules
In our first example, there is a security auditor cross-account IAM role that can be assumed by security automation tools from the central security AWS account. We use the built-in archive rules to automatically archive cross-account findings related to the cross-account security auditor IAM role.
To create a built-in archive rule
- In the AWS Management Console, choose Identity and Access Management (IAM). On the dashboard, choose Access Analyzer, and then choose Archive rules.
- Choose the Create archive rule button.
- You can select archive rule criteria based on your use case. For this example, in the search box, choose AWS Account as the criteria, since we want to automatically archive the security auditor account.
- You can now enter the value for the selected criteria. In this case, for Criteria, choose AWS Account, and then choose the equals operator.
- After you’ve entered your criteria, choose the Create archive rule button.
You should see a message confirming that you’ve successfully created a new archive rule.
How to automatically archive expected findings
We now show you how to automatically archive expected findings by using a serverless workflow that you define by using AWS Step Functions. We show you how to leverage Step Functions to enrich an Access Analyzer finding, evaluate the finding against your customized rule engine logic, and finally either archive the finding or send a notification. A CloudWatch Event Rule will trigger the Step Functions workflow when Access Analyzer generates a new finding.
Solution architecture – serverless workflow
The CloudWatch event bus delivers the Access Analyzer findings to the Step Functions workflow. The Step Functions workflow responds to each Access Analyzer finding and either archives the finding for authorized access or sends an Amazon Simple Notification Service (Amazon SNS) email notification for an unauthorized access finding, as shown in figure 5.
The Step Functions workflow enriches the finding and provides contextual information to the rules engine for evaluation, as shown in figure 6. The Access Analyzer finding is either archived or generates an alert, based on the result of the rules engine evaluation and the associated risk level. If you’re interested in remediating the finding, you can learn more by watching the talk AWS re:Invent 2019: [NEW LAUNCH!] Dive Deep into IAM Access Analyzer (SEC309).
This example uses four Lambda functions. One function is for context enrichment, a second function is for rule evaluation logic, a third function is to archive expected findings, and finally a fourth function is to send a notification for findings that require investigation by your security operations team.
First, the enrichment Lambda function retrieves the tags associated with the AWS resource. The following code example retrieves the S3 bucket tags.
The Lambda function can perform additional enrichment beyond looking up tags, such as looking up the AWS KMS key alias, as shown in the next code example.
Next, the evaluation rule Lambda function determines whether the finding is authorized and can be archived, or whether the finding is unauthorized and a notification needs to be generated. In this example, we first check whether the resource is shared publicly and then immediately alert if there’s an unexpected public sharing of a resource. Additionally, we explicitly don’t want public sharing of resources that are tagged Confidential. Our example method checks whether the value “Confidential” is set as the “Data Classification” tag and correspondingly returns False in order to trigger a notification.
Also, we allow cross-account sharing of a key in the development environment with the tag key “IsAllowedToShare” and tag value “true”, tag key “Environment” with tag value “development”, and a key alias of “DevelopmentKey”.
We then use the Choice condition to trigger either the archive or notification step.
The archive Lambda step archives the Access Analyzer finding if a rule is successfully evaluated.
Otherwise, we raise an SNS notification because there is unauthorized resource sharing.
You can deploy the solution through either the AWS Management Console or the AWS Cloud Development Kit (AWS CDK).
Make sure that Access Analyzer is enabled in your AWS account. You can find an AWS CloudFormation template for doing so in the GitHub repository. It’s also possible for you to enable Access Analyzer across your organization by using the scripts for AWS CloudFormation StackSets found in the GitHub repository. See more details in the blog post Enabling AWS IAM Access Analyzer on AWS Control Tower accounts.
To deploy the solution by using the AWS Management Console
- In your security account, launch the template by choosing the following Launch Stack button.
- Provide the following parameter for the security account:
EmailSubscriptionParameter: The email address to receive subscription notifications for any findings that exceed your defined risk level.
To deploy the solution by using the AWS CDK
Additionally, you can find the latest code on GitHub, where you can also contribute to the sample code. The following commands shows how to deploy the solution by using the AWS Cloud Development Kit (AWS CDK). First, upload the Lambda assets to S3. Then, deploy the solution to your account.
To test the solution
- Create a cross-account KMS key. You should receive an email notification after several minutes.
- Create a cross-account KMS key with the tags IsAllowedToShare=true and Environment=development. Also, create a KMS key alias named alias/DevelopmentKey for this key. After a few seconds, you should see that the finding was automatically archived.
In this blog post, we showed you how IAM Access Analyzer can help you identify resources in your organization and accounts that are shared with an external identity. We explained how to automatically archive expected findings by using the built-in archive rules. Then, we walked you through how to automatically archive expected shared resources. We showed you how to create a serverless workflow that uses AWS Step Functions, which performs context enrichment and then automatically archives your findings for expected shared resources.
After you follow the steps in this blog post for automatic archiving, you will only receive Access Analyzer findings for unexpected AWS resource sharing. A good way to manage these unexpected Access Analyzer findings is with AWS Security Hub, alongside your other findings. Visit Getting started with AWS Security Hub to learn more. You can also see the blog post Automated Response and Remediation with AWS Security Hub for event patterns and remediation code examples.
If you have feedback about this post, submit comments in the Comments section below.
Want more AWS Security how-to content, news, and feature announcements? Follow us on Twitter.